If you move a role offshore, is that a redundancy, a TUPE transfer, or something your employment lawyer hasn’t been asked about yet?
It’s a question more UK businesses are sitting with right now than at any point in recent memory. This year’s employers’ NI increase has pushed the true cost of hiring an employee UK-side well past what most budgets planned for, and the honest cost of employing someone in the UK, salary plus updated employer NI rates, plus pension, plus everything else that sits under recruitment costs- is prompting a lot of leadership teams to look at where else that role could sit. Offshoring is one answer. But before anyone reaches for a redundancy letter or a new offshore contract, there’s a legal question that has to be answered first, and getting it wrong is expensive in ways that have nothing to do with exchange rates.
At Opvia, we build dedicated offshore teams in India for UK businesses across technology, finance, marketing, sales and support. We’re not an alternative to redundancy in the sense of helping you manage one; we’re the reason a lot of our clients never have to send that letter at all: the UK role stays as it is, and a new dedicated team member picks up the growth work you couldn’t afford to hire for locally. This guide walks through when offshoring a role is genuinely a redundancy situation, when TUPE applies instead, what UK law requires either way, and where Opvia’s model changes the calculation entirely.
Why This Decision Is Landing on More Desks Right Now
The trigger is almost always cost. This year’s national insurance increase alone has added a meaningful percentage to the cost of every UK salary on the books, and updated employer ni rates show up in every payroll forecast whether the business is growing or standing still. Once you add pension contributions, sick pay, holiday pay and management overhead on top, the true cost of an employee is routinely 25–40% above the headline salary, and the cost of hiring an employee UK-side for a new or replacement role can be harder to justify than it was two years ago.
That’s the backdrop against which “should we offshore this role” and “should we make this role redundant” end up on the same page of the same board pack. They’re not the same decision, and treating them as interchangeable is where UK employers get into legal trouble.
Redundancy or TUPE Transfer? The Question You Must Answer First
TUPE, the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations, is the single most important piece of TUPE law UK employers need to understand before touching an offshore decision. TUPE meaning, in plain terms: when a business activity transfers to a new employer or provider and keeps its identity, the affected employees transfer with it, on their existing terms, rather than being made redundant.
The TUPE regulations were built for domestic outsourcing and business sales, and applying them to a genuine offshore move- work leaving the UK for a team in India- is where things get less clear-cut than most employers expect. A tupe transfer requires an organised grouping of employees carrying out an identifiable activity, and cross-border cases have gone both ways in the tribunals depending on exactly how the work was organised beforehand. This is not a box you can tick from a template; it needs a proper look at your specific structure before you decide whether you’re managing a transfer or a redundancy.
When TUPE Applies to Offshoring, and When It Doesn’t
The TUPE process only engages where there’s a relevant transfer: the activity has to keep its identity after it moves, and there has to be an organised grouping of staff assigned to it. A role that simply disappears, with the work absorbed into a different function or dropped altogether, isn’t a transfer at all, and redundancy is the right route. A role where the same work continues, just performed by a different team under a different employer, is where TUPE has the potential to apply, even when that team sits outside the UK.
Get advice before assuming either answer. Treating a TUPE situation as a redundancy, to avoid the obligation to transfer staff on existing terms, is one of the more common ways UK employers end up facing an employment tribunal.
It’s worth getting familiar with the TUPE regulations directly rather than relying on a summary from a colleague who dealt with one three years ago: TUPE law in the UK has moved on in places since the original 2006 regulations, and the TUPE process itself- informing and consulting appropriate representatives, then implementing the transfer on the agreed date- has specific timing requirements that catch employers out. If your grasp of the TUPE meaning stops at “employees transfer when a business changes hands,” that’s not wrong, but it’s not the whole picture either, particularly once a border is involved.
If It Is a Genuine Redundancy: What UK Law Requires
Where the role genuinely disappears from the business, rather than transferring anywhere, ordinary redundancy law applies in full. That means consultation with the affected employee (collective consultation if 20 or more roles are at risk within 90 days), fair and objective redundancy selection criteria if you’re choosing between several employees, proper notice period redundancy requirements, and consideration of any suitable alternative role before you confirm the decision.
On pay: employees with two or more years of continuous service are entitled to statutory redundancy pay, calculated from age, length of service and weekly pay up to a statutory cap. Many employers offer more than the statutory minimum for voluntary redundancy specifically, to encourage people to come forward, while compulsory redundancy is typically limited to the statutory figure unless the contract says otherwise. Redundancy payments handled properly, with the right selection criteria and a documented process, are one of the lowest-risk ways to close a role. Handled as an afterthought to an offshoring decision that was already made, they’re one of the highest-risk.
Getting It Wrong: The Unfair Dismissal Risk
This is where the legal and the commercial questions meet. If a role is dismissed as “redundant” but the real reason is that the work has moved to an offshore team and a TUPE transfer should have applied instead, the employee has grounds for an unfair dismissal claim, and in some circumstances an automatic unfair dismissal claim, which doesn’t require the usual two years of service to bring. Unfair dismissal compensation isn’t capped in the same way as redundancy pay, and a tribunal that finds the redundancy was a smokescreen for offshoring will not look kindly on the process that got you there.
The practical takeaway: decide honestly which situation you’re actually in, TUPE or redundancy, before you touch a letter or a contract, not after.
The Cost Question Behind the Decision
Strip away the legal question for a moment, and the commercial one is straightforward. The cost of hiring an employee UK-side, once you account for the true cost of an employee rather than just the headline salary, has to be weighed against what it actually costs to keep, replace, or offshore the role. The cost of employing someone in the UK includes employer NI (already climbing after this year’s employer’s NI increase), pension contributions, sick pay, management time and the recruitment costs of replacing anyone who leaves. None of that changes if you make a role redundant; you’ll still be paying to recruit for the work eventually, just somewhere else, later, under more pressure.
This is the calculation Opvia’s own clients run before they get anywhere near a redundancy conversation: what does it cost to keep growing the team the way we’ve always done it, absorbing every future National Insurance increase along with it, versus what does it cost to add a dedicated offshore hire instead.
What Changes When You Build a Dedicated Offshore Team Instead of Making a Redundancy
The comparison below is the one we walk UK clients through most often. It assumes the same underlying question: we need this work done more cheaply, but shows how differently it plays out depending on which route you take.
| Making the Role Redundant | Building a Dedicated Offshore Team with Opvia | |
| Legal process | Consultation, selection criteria, notice, statutory pay | No redundancy process needed — you’re building new capacity, not cutting a role |
| Risk if handled wrong | Unfair dismissal claim, tribunal costs | None of the redundancy risk applies |
| What happens to the work | Reassigned, dropped, or later re-hired elsewhere | Picked up immediately by a dedicated team member |
| Cost | Statutory pay, notice pay, possible tribunal costs, then a fresh recruitment cost | One flat monthly fee, no hidden costs |
| Who employs the new hire | N/A | Opvia — no UK or Indian legal entity required from you |
The reason this matters isn’t just cost. A redundancy closes a role and opens legal exposure if the reasoning doesn’t hold up; a dedicated offshore team adds capacity without touching anyone’s existing UK contract at all. For most of the UK businesses we work with, offshoring was never about replacing someone; it was about affording to grow into work they’d already won.
Opvia’s Advantage: How We Do It For You
Opvia is the named legal employer for your dedicated team member in India, so there’s no UK or Indian entity for you to set up, and no ambiguity about who’s liable for what. Because you’re building new capacity rather than transferring or closing an existing UK role, the TUPE and redundancy questions covered in this guide simply don’t arise: your existing team stays exactly as it is. You get one flat monthly fee with no hidden costs stacking on top the way they do with a UK hire, and a dedicated India-based Project Manager who owns the relationship day to day.
Read more about how Opvia builds your dedicated offshore team, or see what a role would cost with Opvia’s pricing and cost calculator.
If you’re weighing up a redundancy against offshoring a role, get in touch to talk through your options before you commit to either. We’ll tell you honestly whether a dedicated offshore hire solves the problem you actually have.
FAQs
Is offshoring a role automatically a redundancy?
A: Not automatically. If the work itself still exists but moves to a new provider or location, it may be a TUPE transfer rather than a redundancy. If the role genuinely disappears from the UK business with no equivalent transfer, redundancy rules apply instead.
Does TUPE apply when a role is moved to an offshore team in India?
A: It can, but it isn’t automatic. TUPE applies when there’s a “relevant transfer” of an organised grouping of employees or activities. Cross-border offshoring makes this harder to assess than a domestic outsourcing deal, so get advice on your specific case before assuming either way.
What is not covered by TUPE?
A: Share sales, the transfer of public administrative functions, and situations with no organised grouping of employees carrying out the activity are generally outside TUPE. A one-off, single-event task is also unlikely to qualify.
Can an employee be made redundant after a TUPE transfer?
A: Yes, but only for genuine economic, technical or organisational reasons entailing changes in the workforce. Redundancy that’s really just cover for offshoring the work is where employers run into unfair dismissal claims.
What are the stages of a fair redundancy process?
A: Broadly: identify the need, consult with affected employees (collectively if 20 or more roles are at risk), apply fair and objective redundancy selection criteria, consider suitable alternative employment, then confirm with proper notice period redundancy requirements and statutory redundancy pay.
How much statutory redundancy pay is an employee entitled to?
A: It’s based on age, length of service and weekly pay, up to a statutory cap, for employees with two or more years of continuous service. Voluntary redundancy packages often enhance redundancy payments above the statutory minimum; compulsory redundancy typically doesn’t.
What happens if we get the redundancy vs TUPE call wrong?
A: The most common outcome is an unfair dismissal claim, and if the true position was TUPE, the employee may also argue they were dismissed because of the transfer itself, which carries automatic unfair dismissal risk regardless of length of service. Unfair dismissal compensation can add up quickly once a tribunal decides the redundancy reasoning didn’t hold up.
Is it cheaper to make a role redundant or build an offshore team instead?
A: Redundancy carries statutory pay, notice pay and tribunal risk if it’s mishandled, and you still need to recruit for the work eventually. Building a dedicated offshore team sidesteps the redundancy question entirely because the UK role isn’t disappearing; you’re adding capacity elsewhere.